As a builder, i have been asked this question probably more than any other. The answer is an unequivocal…maybe! It depends on several things. What is the value of your home? How much do you have to spend? And, how long do you plan to stay in your home?
Everything else aside, how much is your home worth? It is typical to spend 6 – 10% of your home’s value in a kitchen remodel. That is for cabinets, tops, appliances and flooring- for now we are not moving any walls. Of course, depending on the condition and age of your existing kitchen, you might want to just spend half of that budget and reface the cabinets, and add new tops and appliances.
How much you spend is dependant on the size of the project as well as how much of the work you will do yourself. Labor can be as much as 1/2 or as little as 1/3 of the project. A big enough chunk of change that you might want to spend Saturdays at your local home center’s renovation classes to brush up on your skills. This is a good time to hone your shopping skills. Many stores have display models or closeouts that are at a big discount. This savings is a great way to grow equity in your home.
How long you plan to stay in your home can play a large role in deciding if that renovation is a reasonable thing to do. If you plan to be in your home for more than five years, the cost of the renovation work would make more sense than if you planned to sell the house right away. This is because, in general, a freshly renovated kitchen will only return a fraction of the cost involved when the house is sold- you won’t get your entire renovation cost back. If your older home is dated, but in good working order, you might want to keep the sales price as low as you can and sell the house the way it is rather than renovate and try to recover that cost at the sale.
If you plan to stay in your home for a while, the cost of a renovation is more of a comfort and personal issue than a investment one. At that point, you will be getting personal enjoyment out of your kitchen renovation bucks, and if you do a lot of the work yourself, a modest jump in the value of your castle.
One last word of caution. Be careful not to overdo your renovation in terms of your neighborhood home values. Also, try to stay more or less mainstream in the design of your new kitchen- no matter how long you plan to stay there. At some point either you or your heirs will need to sell your home. A well thought out kitchen design will only help the sales appeal, while an over-the-top design… not so much.